Roughly 1% of people meet standards for narcissistic character dysfunction (NPD), and 6.2% of individuals meet standards in some unspecified time in the future of their lifetime.1,2 Regardless of this excessive prevalence, clinicians might really feel hesitant to diagnose NPD, and anxious about the way to successfully deal with these sufferers. With no randomized managed trials on psychotherapy for NPD, suppliers typically expertise hopelessness and frustration when treating sufferers with narcissistic challenges.3,4 How can clinicians assist these sufferers, particularly after they can come throughout as so inflexible, self-centered, walled off, and antagonistic?
Mentalization—the power to precisely “learn,” entry, and replicate on psychological states in oneself and others5—gives a promising reply. As a number one evidence-based remedy for people with
Mentalization and Pathological Narcissism
MBT proposes that kids develop the power to mentalize via empathic, attuned interactions with their caregivers.8 This course of will get disrupted in pathological narcissism. Though there are a number of pathways for the event of narcissism,10 analysis means that narcissism is related to parental overvaluation, during which dad and mom relate to their kids as if they’re extra entitled and particular than different kids.12 Relatively than mirroring the kid’s emotional states, the caregiver presents an idealized picture of the kid, one which prioritizes power, achievement, confidence, and positivity. The kid thus internalizes what MBT refers to because the narcissistic alien self—a way of self organized round who the mum or dad feels the kid “ought to” be, which fails to replicate a fancy array of the kid’s precise emotions (eg, insecurity, disappointment, nervousness, needs for care).10,11
As growth unfolds, the individual stays disconnected from their feelings, as an alternative feeling a compulsive must self-enhance by pursuing the exterior situations for his or her shallowness: achievement, attractiveness, intelligence, intercourse, and others’ constructive views of them (
In depth analysis helps this idea, confirming that individuals with narcissism exhibit notable challenges with mentalization: empathic deficits14; alexithymia, or difficulties figuring out and expressing their feelings15; overestimation of their mentalizing talents16; and decreased generosity, which is mediated by decreased perspective-taking talents.17 Disadvantaged of those “mentalizing buffers,” folks with narcissism fall into nonmentalizing modes, or the types of non-reflectiveness that characterize character pathology (
Easy methods to Assist: Stimulate Mentalizing
If issues in mentalizing drive the useful challenges of pathological narcissism, then that means an easy “goal” within the care of those sufferers: serving to them to mentalize. Preliminary proof helps this strategy. In an 18-month outpatient trial, MBT was more practical than generalist remedy for sufferers with better Axis II comorbidity, together with comorbid NPD and BPD. Roughly 75% of sufferers
(25 of 34) in MBT confirmed full restoration on the finish of remedy, in contrast with 25% (6 of 23) in generalist remedy. Sufferers in MBT additionally demonstrated considerably extra speedy enhancements in self-harm, melancholy, social adjustment, and interpersonal functioning.18
In a latest examine of 205 sufferers receiving an amalgam of psychodynamic/cognitive behavioral remedy, researchers confirmed the correlation between pathological narcissism and mentalizing deficits, additionally discovering that the capability to mentalize mediated the connection between narcissism and remedy outcomes (eg, decreased
Formal MBT entails a sequence of preliminary steps, together with discussing the NPD analysis, offering schooling about mentalizing, and collaboratively growing a written “MBT formulation” of sufferers’ distinctive mentalizing vulnerabilities.11 However for practitioners simply getting began with these rules, MBT means that they merely undertake a mentalizing stance of their on a regular basis medical interactions
(
So the dictum is: Relatively than making an announcement, ask a query about what sufferers are going via. This requires a extremely lively medical strategy: directing consideration to particular elements of sufferers’ narratives, and asking open- and closed-ended questions on what they and others might be feeling.
Exploring the What, Why, and How
MBT for narcissism recommends a step-by-step trajectory of interventions, organized across the various kinds of mentalizing (
With this framework in thoughts, MBT recommends a handful of steps when confronting the therapeutic challenges that beset sufferers with narcissism (
For instance, if a affected person is hyperfocused on his anger towards his boss, encourage him to explain a latest interplay intimately (the “what”): “You talked about that your boss was ‘disrespectful’ towards you. What did she truly say?”
Then work to “increase the what” by elaborating the affected person’s feelings associated to susceptible elements of the situation: “When she stated you had accomplished a foul job on the task, how did that make you are feeling about your self?”
If the affected person describes feeling ashamed, mentalize the “why” by encouraging him to take a broader perspective on the emotional panorama: “You had been so in contact together with your anger towards her, however solely vaguely conscious of the disgrace. What do you make of this?”
Lastly, mentalize the “how” by using MBT’s methods for addressing concrete pondering: “May we have a look at this concept somewhat additional—that your boss providing you with constructive suggestions means she doesn’t respect you as a employee?”
MBT in Motion
“Peter,” a 26-year-old second-year medical scholar, is referred for MBT following a suicide try made on the day he was scheduled to take step 1 of the US Medical Licensing Examination. He was medically stabilized after a near-lethal overdose. He has since taken go away from faculty and moved again in along with his dad and mom, who concern he’s retreating from life and at excessive threat of reattempting suicide.
In his first appointment with the MBT clinician, Peter presents in a state of obvious poise, delivering an intellectualized critique of the doctor licensing course of, whereas elevating issues in regards to the clinician’s tutorial credentials. When the clinician asks about his suicide try, he launches right into a vitriolic externalizing description of the “incompetent” professors whom he feels inadequately ready him for the examination.
Noticing that his narrative is generalized, devaluing of others, and devoid of inside emotional expertise, the clinician begins by prioritizing factual clarification over exploring emotions, asking him to explain “simply the info” in regards to the occasions resulting in the suicide try. The clinician regularly shapes this factual timeline right into a mentalizing narrative by asking what feelings arose as he was getting ready for the examination. When Peter reverts again to externalizing devaluation (“These are silly questions”; “These inept professors set me as much as fail”), the clinician doesn’t problem these impressions. As a substitute, the clinician steadily redirects him to explain the “what” of his inside expertise: “What did you are feeling, inside your self, when the professors had been performing that method?”
Peter ultimately names feeling “infuriated” by his professors’ incompetence. The clinician works to “increase the what” by probing for added emotions. Peter acknowledges that he additionally felt anxious about failing the examination, and ashamed about how exhausting it was for him to check and be taught the fabric. Now progressing to MBT’s “why” interventions, the clinician explores Peter’s “emotions about his emotions”: “What was it like so that you can really feel anxious and ashamed in that method?” Peter expresses longstanding discomfort related to susceptible emotions, noting that he feels “highly effective” when indignant and intolerably “humiliated” when afraid and ashamed.
As Peter builds this extra nuanced image of his inside world, the clinician notices his certainty that he would by no means go the examination regardless of meticulous preparations, alongside along with his concrete assumption that failing to develop into a doctor means that he’s nugatory and has no cause to stay. Using MBT’s methods for addressing issues in “how” sufferers are pondering, the clinician helps Peter discover how he arrives at these painful views, in addition to the unfavorable penalties these views have had on his life and shallowness. Over time, Peter begins to really feel extra curious in regards to the clinician’s further perspective that his difficulties would possibly enhance via the method of mentalizing—by figuring out, reflecting upon, and authentically connecting along with his personal psychological states, and the psychological states of different folks.
Concluding Ideas
NPD will be formulated as a dysfunction of mentalizing, characterised by restricted sensitivity to others’ affective states, challenges representing and accessing one’s personal feelings and needs, and a fragmented mentalized self that requires steady self-enhancement. This mentalizing formulation permits practitioners to focus on sufferers’ personalised mentalizing vulnerabilities associated to narcissistic disruptions, as has already been accomplished efficiently within the remedy of BPD and ASPD.6,7 Additional analysis is required to find out the effectiveness of this strategy for pathological narcissism.
Mr Drozek is the medical director of the Mentalization-Based mostly Remedy (MBT) Clinic at McLean Hospital. He additionally serves as a workers psychotherapist within the Gunderson Outpatient Program and the Division of Alcohol, Medication, and Habit at McLean. He’s a coach and supervisor in MBT via the Anna Freud Centre in London, England, and a instructing affiliate within the Division of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical College. Dr Unruh is the medical director of the MBT Clinic and Gunderson Residence at McLean Hospital. He’s a coach and supervisor in MBT via the Anna Freud Centre, and an teacher within the Division of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical College. Dr Bateman is a advisor psychiatrist, psychotherapist, and MBT coordinator on the Anna Freud Centre. He’s additionally a visiting professor on the College Faculty of London, in England, and an honorary professor in psychotherapy on the College of Copenhagen, in Denmark. For extra details about MBT, go to
References
1. Dhawan N, Kunik ME, Oldham J, Coverdale J.
2. Ronningstam E.
3. Finch EF, Mellen EJ.
4. Tanzilli A, Muzi L, Ronningstam E, Lingiardi V.
5. Drozek RP. Mentalization: Using Reflection to Heal from Borderline Persona Dysfunction. Oxford College Press; 2025.
6. Fonagy P, Simes E, Yirmiya Ok, et al.
7. Storebø OJ, Stoffers-Winterling JM, Völlm BA, et al.
8. Bateman A, Fonagy P. Mentalization-Based mostly Remedy for Persona Issues: A Sensible Information. Oxford College Press; 2016.
9. Bateman A, Fonagy P, Campbell C, et al. Cambridge Information to Mentalization-Based mostly Remedy (MBT). Cambridge College Press; 2023.
10. Drozek RP, Unruh BT.
11. Drozek RP, Unruh BT, Bateman AW. Mentalization-Based mostly Remedy for Pathological Narcissism: A Handbook. Oxford College Press; 2023.
12. Kılıçkaya S, Uçar N, Denizci Nazlıgül M.
13. Krizan Z, Herlache AD.
14. Urbonaviciute G, Hepper EG.
15. Chaim CH, Almeida TM, de Vries Albertin P, et al.
16. Duval J, Ensink Ok, Normandin L, Fonagy P.
17. Böckler A, Sharifi M, Kanske P, Dziobek I, Singer T.
18. Bateman A, Fonagy P.
19. Euler S, Hüwe L, Gablonski TC, et al.
20. Puder D. Psychiatry & Psychotherapy. Pathological narcissism: efficient remedy with mentalization-based remedy (MBT). Interview with Robert P. Drozek, Brandon T. Unruh, and Anthony Bateman. November 15, 2024. Accessed October 4, 2025.