SPECIAL REPORT: DIVERSITY
Indigenous communities throughout the US and globally expertise disproportionate charges of trauma, psychological sickness, poverty, and institutional distrust. Regardless of these realities, dominant fashions of psychological well being remedy pathologize Indigenous behaviors and beliefs, ignoring systemic oppression and intergenerational trauma. This text explores what’s lacking in psychological well being observe for Indigenous populations and introduces decolonizing, culturally grounded fashions of care.
What Is Lacking: Colonized Psychological Well being Fashions
Western psychiatry and medical observe typically isolate signs from social and historic context. This framework invalidates Indigenous data methods, communal values, and therapeutic traditions, changing them with Eurocentric norms. Psychological well being professionals steadily misread conventional parenting or survival methods as dysfunction. For instance, anticipating adolescents to contribute financially to the family might mirror cultural interdependence, not neglect. Moreover, households from numerous cultural backgrounds rely closely on each other and sometimes have interaction in shared caregiving duties. This interconnectedness can typically be misinterpreted as enmeshment, slightly than being understood by way of a communal or collectivist cultural lens.
These misinterpretations result in punitive interventions. One such instance is baby protecting companies (CPS), which can view Indigenous parenting by way of a deficit lens, typically pressuring households to assimilate into White middle-class norms to keep up custody of their kids.1
Case Vignette 1
“Calista,” an Indigenous Guatemalan mom with no formal schooling and a historical past of trauma, was referred to CPS for parenting issues, together with poor supervision and inconsistent faculty attendance. CPS seen her expectations of a mid-teenager contributing to hire and work as inappropriate.
By an in-home assist program led by a clinician grounded in a decolonizing framework, Calista and her household had been approached with cultural sensitivity and an understanding of their historic context. As a substitute of pathologizing Calista’s parenting, the clinician highlighted her strengths, particularly her resilience and dedication to household unity—whereas additionally recognizing the systemic and historic forces that formed her experiences.
When it got here to the household’s monetary hardship, the clinician created a protected house for the eldest daughter to share her perspective. The youth spoke about her deep love for her household, the intense poverty that led them to depart their residence nation, and her function in contributing to hire because the oldest sibling. She additionally spoke about her distrust of CPS and feeling that issues had been worse off with their involvement. She shared that she selected to depart her residence and hire a bed room on her personal, given the challenges she and her household had been going through. By her dwelling independently and reflection in classes, she acknowledged the distinctive burden she carried in contrast along with her youthful siblings, who had been raised primarily in the US. She famous how working at a younger age was obligatory in her context however could be thought of inappropriate or pointless in her siblings’ extra economically secure upbringing.
This perception helped reframe her expertise not as exploitation however as an expression of care, sacrifice, and cultural accountability. The youth was then in a position to transfer ahead and work towards acquiring her highschool diploma by way of an grownup schooling program whereas additionally preserving a job to assist herself. She additionally continued to see her household and siblings. The clinician’s strategy to bridging was neither shaming nor punitive. The intent was to not endorse underage employment however slightly to satisfy the youth the place she was at, with empathy and cultural humility—acknowledging the independence, accountability, care, motivation, and resilience she has developed by way of her expertise. The clinician additionally needed to do their half in educating themselves on the historical past of the Indigenous inhabitants they had been serving and to grasp the historic and generational traumas that underpinned the household’s story, and to uplift the resilience and humanity that they had.
A decolonizing strategy requires this delicate stability: supporting the household’s distinctive wants whereas additionally guaranteeing security to forestall additional CPS involvement. On this case, it meant the youth refusing to see CPS however permitting herself to make the most of the assist of the in-home program that CPS put in place and funded. The strengths she possessed had been then reframed as protecting components that would assist her monetary literacy and contribute to her long-term objectives and self-determined future.
When servicing households, it’s by way of modeling and actions that one will be an exemplar to others within the area who will not be accustomed to or learn about this lens and strategy. This strategy helped forestall household separation and demonstrated the essential worth of culturally grounded care.
What Works: A Decolonizing Medical Framework
1. Neurodecolonization and mindfulness: Neurodecolonization acknowledges how colonization shapes mind responses and trauma expression. Mindfulness rooted in Indigenous traditions can regulate the nervous system and promote therapeutic.2 This consists of grounding, storytelling, and rituals tied to cultural identification, which supply extra relevance than Western therapeutic methods alone.3
2. Trauma-informed, culturally responsive parenting assist: Packages should adapt to the literacy, language, and experiences of Indigenous households.1,4 As a substitute of imposing behavioral norms, clinicians ought to validate survival methods and cocreate culturally aligned parenting plans.5 For instance, if the guardian doesn’t learn or write, supporting the way in which they discover best to navigate their world is extra useful than inserting judgment about their lack of literacy expertise or pushing them to take English lessons. If the guardian solutions her telephone reliably and doesn’t use textual content message, then the clinician should shift their expectations and norms to that of the shopper. If there was a priority across the guardian’s engagement in companies and the guardian has 2 jobs and isn’t in a position to attend, it could be most moral to supply an early Saturday session to satisfy the household’s actuality. If the parental subgroup had earlier problem setting boundaries round who was coming into the house, a plan may very well be that the guardian will work with the clinician in setting boundaries with household or unfamiliar people and contemplating different choices to collect with mates in order that the youngsters within the residence really feel protected always.
3. Cultural genograms and speaking circles: These instruments permit households to map intergenerational trauma and resilience. Speaking circles, particularly, create communal therapeutic areas the place relations are seen, heard, and affirmed.4 Provided that psychological well being professionals have perpetuated the methods of considering of the West, developing a binational genogram was reportedly useful with migrants experiencing the transitions and tribulations of crossing borders.3 Bilingual social employees skilled in biculturality and using pure serving to and community-based therapeutic had been efficient in working with Latine communities.3
Therapeutic circles have been proven to facilitate resilience and assist inside undocumented communities.6,7 In line with the Speaking Circle for Younger Adults (TC4YA) intervention, they’ve demonstrated vital enhancements in stress discount, cultural identification, and behavioral well being outcomes amongst Indigenous youth.6
Decolonizing Supervision: Supporting Moral Follow
In the US, Indigenous individuals have poorer well being outcomes in contrast with different populations. The US Census Bureau reported in 2018 that Indigenous communities had a poverty fee of 23.7% in contrast with 9.3% for non-Hispanic White People. Some Indigenous communities have 50% poverty charges.8 This demonstrates the destructive impacts of systemic oppression. In the US, European settlers engaged in battle for land and introduced illness, ensuing within the demise of 99% of Indigenous individuals.
The Nationwide Affiliation of Social Employees’ Code of Ethics, ethics in analysis, and the Council on Social Work Schooling count on social employees to assist the self-determination of oppressed teams,9,10 underscoring the alliance wanted from psychological well being professionals with Indigenous communities in addition to emphasizing the accountability of supporting justice, beneficence, and respect.
One of many present challenges in advancing decolonizing supervision is the affect of neoliberalism on social work, which reinforces managerial priorities and limits relational depth within the area. Unstated norms—comparable to discouraging private disclosure or implementing inflexible boundaries—can forestall clinicians from partaking in actually genuine supervision. By decentering (slightly than rejecting) Western frameworks and integrating Indigenous and culturally grounded practices, supervision can change into extra aligned with social work’s core moral values.11,12 For example, a supervisor may misread a clinician’s effort to include alternative routes of understanding as overidentifying with the shopper, slightly than recognizing it as a culturally responsive strategy to understanding the shopper by way of a distinct lens.
Horizontal Approaches
The historical past of social work and different psychological well being professions will be strengthened by honoring a wider vary of ancestors and data traditions. Doing so presents numerous views on how the career is known and practiced all over the world. Illustration issues—when individuals see function fashions who mirror their identities and experiences, it helps them envision a significant path ahead. As a result of Western frameworks have a tendency to emphasise individualism, social employees and supervisors should additionally study from Indigenous views that worth neighborhood, shared accountability, and horizontal relationships.
Supervisors, particularly, ought to mirror on how their very own private {and professional} histories form their strategy to management. It’s important to acknowledge the colonial roots embedded in dominant methods of considering to keep away from unintentionally reinforcing oppressive methods. Many evidence-based practices are constructed on positivist epistemologies, which regularly exclude or silence different legitimate methods of understanding. To be actually inclusive, evidence-based approaches should make house for a number of methods of understanding and therapeutic.2
Mayor and Pollack emphasize the Indigenous worldview as interconnected with the neighborhood, land, and holistic identification.12,13 The helper is seen of their entirety. Reflexive practices should transcend efficiency; they require understanding one’s complicity in oppression and appearing accordingly.12,13
Social work as a career is world, but its acknowledged founders are predominantly Western. Decolonizing supervision helps present a decentered perspective. Recognizing solely Western founders erases different data methods and methods of being.1 Whereas one African mannequin gives an area strategy, there’s a want for literature particular to Indigenous populations who’ve migrated and are navigating the strain between resistance and assimilation.
Referencing Laenui’s mannequin of decolonization and Engelbrecht’s 3 phases (decolonization, authentication, and software) utilized in South Africa, US-based psychological well being professionals can adapt a localized mannequin to mitigate the hurt attributable to hegemonic supervisory practices. Laenui’s phases of decolonization have to be thought of when advocating for oneself and supervisees. Engelbrecht’s framework can information localized supervision fashions.11 Utilizing positionality, supervisors ought to mirror on their very own lenses and the way they affect supervision.12
Case Vignette 2
“Sara,” a Guatemalan immigrant, feels related to her Indigenous roots and is in varied phases of decoloniality. She resides on the Native lands of the Quinnipiac, Paugussett, and Wappinger peoples.14 Having skilled colonial trauma in her native nation, she wrestles along with her combined identification of carrying indigeneity and European roots. Supervisors supporting communities like Sara’s should embed the three phases of decolonization and the 5 steps in genuine supervision into observe.15 Doing so presents a pathway out of assimilationist norms and towards authenticity. Engelbrecht outlines standards for genuine social work supervision, which will be discovered within the Desk.6
TABLE. Engelbrecht’s Standards for Genuine Social Work Supervision
Reflections From the Entrance Line
I carry my sufferers’ tales, struggles, energy, and love with me in each breath. A hiatus is just not about forgetting what I’ve seen or felt in the neighborhood; it’s about restoring the vitality I would like to point out up extra wholly. I step again to replenish, to mirror, and to return again stronger, extra organized, and extra ready to proceed standing beside my sufferers and friends. I’m not above them. I don’t serve them as an outsider. I serve with them, as one in every of them—nothing much less and nothing extra. They’re my individuals. They’ve at all times proven up for me, and it’s their spirit that offers me the energy to heal others. The love, the resistance, and the resilience I’ve witnessed is what fuels my very own therapeutic.
However let me be clear: My anger is actual. The issues I’ve witnessed—households harmed by methods that faux to assist, cultures misunderstood or erased, kids pathologized for surviving—have lit a hearth in me. That fireside is just not bitter; it’s objective. It’s what motivates me to maintain returning, to maintain combating, to maintain holding house for the neighborhood to heal, to reclaim, and to retain our stunning tradition and sacred methods of being.
Reimagining Psychological Well being for Indigenous Communities
To fulfill the moral obligation of social work and guarantee relevance to native populations, psychological well being clinicians have to have a decolonizing strategy when working with people that carry Indigenous roots. Supervision should even be decolonized.2 This includes increasing its scope, embracing cultural data, and resisting the positivist, assimilationist, and colonial frameworks which have lengthy dominated the sphere.2 Decolonizing supervision requires consideration to positionality, essential reflection, and native cultural understanding.11 Supervisors ought to mannequin humility, encourage reflexivity, and problem institutional norms that devalue Indigenous data.10
To adequately serve Indigenous communities, psychological well being methods should do greater than combine cultural components into present Western paradigms. They need to reimagine their foundations. This consists of decentering Eurocentric assumptions, embracing Indigenous epistemologies, and committing to relational, community-oriented care.11
Therapeutic isn’t just medical. It’s historic, cultural, and political. Psychological well being professionals should companion with Indigenous communities to collectively create pathways of liberation and therapeutic that restore what colonization has tried to erase.
Dr Gereda is a social employee in New Haven, Connecticut. Her opinions are her personal.
References
1. Choate PW. The decision to decolonise: social work’s problem for working with Indigenous peoples. Br J Soc Work. 2019;49(4):1081-1099.
2. Clarke Okay. Reimagining social work ancestry: towards epistemic decolonization. Affilia. 2021;37(2):266-278.
3. Grey M, Coates J, Fowl MY, Hetherington T. Decolonizing Social Work. Routledge; 2016.
4. Morales FR, González Vera JM, Silva MA, et al. An exploratory examine of therapeutic circles as a technique to facilitate resilience in an undocumented neighborhood. J Lat Psychol. 2023;11(2):119-133.
5. Anastas JW. Ethics in analysis. In: Encyclopedia of Social Work. Oxford College Press; 2013.
6. Lowe J, Millender E, Greatest O. Speaking Circle for Younger Adults (TC4YA) intervention: a culturally protected analysis exemplar. Contemp Nurse. 2022;58(1):95-107.
7. Mehl-Madrona L, Mainguy B. Introducing therapeutic circles and speaking circles into major care. Perm J. 2014;18(2):4-9.
8. American Group Survey. US Census Bureau. 2018. Accessed July 7, 2025. https://www.census.gov
9. Weaver HN. Native People overview. In: Encyclopedia of Social Work. Oxford College Press; 2013.
10. Nationwide Affiliation of Social Employees. Code of Ethics. NASW Press; 2021.
11. Engelbrecht LK. In direction of genuine supervision of social employees in South Africa. Clin Supervisor. 2019;38(2):301-325.
12. Mayor C, Pollack S. Inventive writing and decolonizing intersectional feminist essential reflexivity: difficult neoliberal, gendered, white, colonial observe norms within the COVID-19 pandemic. Affilia. 2022;37(3):382-395.
13. Smith LT. Decolonizing Methodologies: Analysis and Indigenous Peoples. third ed. Zed Books; 2021.
14. Native Land. October 8, 2021. Accessed July 7, 2025. https://native-land.ca/
15. Laenui P. Processes of decolonization. In: Battiste M, ed. Reclaiming Indigenous Voice and Imaginative and prescient. UBC Press; 2006:150-160.